//
you're reading...
The Straits Times

Balanced Discourse On Voluntourism

When we help with painting and cleaning up the school, it helps with team building and also improves the environment for the children there” (‘Voluntours’ Growing In Popularity In Singapore, Miss Audrey Tan).

It might be encouraging that the number of Singaporeans who head abroad to volunteer has more than doubled from 300 in 2011 to 750 last year (Mar. 10), but this optimism should be tempered with greater scepticism. That means frank discourse over the benefits and harm caused by the tours, listening to the perspectives of the locals who have hosted groups of voluntourists, and putting more deserving enterprises involved in sustainable ventures – which often have comparatively substantial impact – in the spotlight.

The same questions have been asked of students on overseas community service projects. The way photographs are taken and presented on social media has been challenged too.

There is little doubt that the volunteers themselves benefit tremendously when they take in the sights and sounds in a foreign country, while doing some good for beneficiaries. In fact the aforementioned commentary featured individuals proclaiming who “are keen to make a difference”, that tours “help with team building and also improve the environment for the children”. Many would insist that they participate in these projects with the best of intentions, that they mean and do no harm, and that at the very least they create something tangible.

Yet the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

The point is not to pass generalised judgements on these volunteer endeavours – to paint an unrealistically rosy picture of voluntours or to conveniently dismiss them as being detrimental – but to be realistic about contributions.

The point is not to pass generalised judgements on these volunteer endeavours – to paint an unrealistically rosy picture of voluntours or to conveniently dismiss them as being detrimental – but to be realistic about contributions. During the construction of facilities are volunteers a hindrance, when inexperience leads to sloppy and inefficient outcomes and local workers end up re-doing the “work”? Do the children genuinely need the one-time language or art lessons, or do we inconvenience with the need for translators and additional material? What are the implications of our visits: do voluntourists objectify students and communities, create impositions, or presume (non-existent) needs?

And rather than emphasising these ad hoc undertakings why not highlight committed enterprises involved in a community for an extended period, or highlight how these transient manpower contribute to these broader projects. The ST article struck me because it failed to cast an ounce of doubt over these voluntours. In the same vein cynics like me should also realise there are good people doing good long-term work, who might value such manpower.

A balanced discourse on voluntourism – incorporating retrospective insights from voluntourists, feedback from non-government organisations and the beneficiaries, and an evaluation of the long-term contributions – will set a proper tone for future undertakings. And reduce this predilection to promote voluntourism merely as a superficial means for Singaporeans to “fulfil their wanderlust charitably”.

Advertisements

About guanyinmiao

A man of knowledge lives by acting, not by thinking about acting. Carlos Castaneda.

Discussion

3 thoughts on “Balanced Discourse On Voluntourism

  1. Looks like you were overseas during the YMCA Conversations series on OCIPs: Boon Or Bane? featuring hwachong’s very own Teo Ming Ern, EC for Artemis. (22nd Feb)
    Was pretty enlightening hearing the perspectives of those that send people on such trips, and continue to do so.
    My takeaways here: http://drateramal.livejournal.com/143890.html

    Posted by drateramal | March 16, 2014, 10:50 pm
    • Thanks for the link. Did they share more? I’d be interested to hear about how the long-term volunteers match their volunteers’ abilities to the needs of the communities (and also, how these needs are ascertained, and how goals are evaluated).

      Jin Yao

      Posted by guanyinmiao | March 17, 2014, 2:19 am

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: When Is Volunteerism, Volunteerism? | guanyinmiao's musings - January 6, 2016

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow guanyinmiao's musings on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,211 other followers

Twitter

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

%d bloggers like this: